Conference contribution EASST/4S 2024 in Amsterdam

At the EASST/4S conference in Amsterdam, Martina Klausner spoke on the panel ‘Voicing Places’ about the intertwining of data and politics. Her narrative ranged from the acoustic diversity of signals and noises in urban street space to the invisible and inaudible signals written and transmitted by induction loops, sensors and scanners. She explained why car data is omnipresent in Frankfurt’s data landscape, while data on other forms of mobility is only available to a very limited extent and is manually stitched together into data patches on an ad hoc basis. The presentation explored the question of how politics is inscribed in data assemblages and how these data ultimately express political meanings themselves.

Street noise: tracing data politics in urban traffic infrastructures

Panel

Voicing Places

Author

Martina Klausner

Abstract

In my contribution I seek to listen to the different signals that are generated as part of urban traffic and administrative information infrastructures and how the resulting data assemble voice politics in different forms.

Urban streets are filled with noise: roaring engines, chatting neighbours, bicycle bells, all voicing demands for their space in public place. Unheard and mostly unnoticed by road users, other signals fill the urban public space: inductors embedded in the asphalt of the road generate and transmit signals, indicating the numbers and movement of (some) road users and ultimately form the basis for the planning and monitoring of the city’s traffic. My contribution to the panel seeks to listen to these signals and asks how they participate in the politics of redistributing space for urban traffic. As part of the historically grown traffic and administrative information infrastructures, traffic data are assembled in particular ways.

Read more

To no surprise, signals counting cars and controlling their flows and stops have been central for the development of traffic data infrastructures. Just as cars dominate the roads, traffic data infrastructures are also primarily populated by car data. However, my interest is less on the quantity of certain data but on the trails and forms that data take and how they assemble and voice political claims in different ways. While car data are meant to flow continuously, data on bicycle traffic are knit together in what I call data patches: context-specific and issue-related data collections that span various sources, times and places, enabling different data stories and politics.

Workshop at the Ethnography Studio at USC 2024

In September 2024, as part of a research trip to Los Angeles, we organised the workshop „Missing, Underappreciated, Found“ together with Andrea Ballestero as part of the Ethnography Studio and discussed our research on the topic of „Maps and Models as Machine Ethnography“ with colleagues.

With the Ethnography Studio at the University of Southern California in Los Angeles, Andrea Ballestero and Katie Ulrich have created a forum that brings together ethnographers from various disciplines – from art and engineering to anthropology, computer science and sociology. Here, researchers experiment with new approaches to understanding complex social phenomena. A guiding principle is that the uncertainties and ambiguities of ethnographic research prove valuable for creative thinking. The studio embraces a diversity of methods and theoretical perspectives and values contradictions over coherence. Members develop their projects and research ideas in a collaborative space where they ask each other challenging questions.

During a river tour on the second day of the workshop, we gained exciting insights into the more-than-human assemblages that make up the infrastructure of Los Angeles.

„Missing, Underappreciated, Found“

The workshop Missing, Underappreciated, Found” examined the transitional devices that ethnographers encounter or create themselves in their work to develop their research projects. The aim was to highlight the possibilities that these ethnographic tools (such as satellite maps, databases, quantitative models) open up when their use complements established ethnographic methods such as participant observation and interviews.

In addition to our project group, two other projects presented their ongoing research: Labyrinth (UCLA) and Expanding the Social World Downwards (USC).

Read more

In our own article, entitled Maps and Models as Machine Ethnography, we examined how digital mapping and quantitative models as tools and objects of ethnographic research enable exciting perspectives and insights. We compared two objects: the new traffic model being developed by engineers in the city of Frankfurt and our own experimental mapping of the complex landscape of actors and data in the context of the mobility transition in Frankfurt, which we created using the digital graph visualisation software Gephi. In doing so, we showed how these digital models and maps are not representations of reality, but rather, in their reduction of complex interrelationships, are themselves world-shaping and actively shape and expand ethnographic research and its questions.